On the night of November 2, a little after eight o’clock, a Milwaukee police sergeant fired ten rounds on Highway 175 and killed a fifty-year-old man named Joseph M. Harry.
Fourteen days later the department released about ninety seconds of video. It came from the camera mounted in the sergeant’s vehicle, because there was no camera on his chest.
He was not breaking a rule. That is the sentence worth sitting with, and it is the thread running through everything Milwaukee learned this week.
Milwaukee Police Department policy does not require sergeants and other ranking officers to wear body cameras. Chief Jeffrey Norman has said it plainly: only patrol officers, not sergeants, have body-worn cameras. So on a freeway, at night, with no other officer present, the one person who discharged a weapon was the one person who by policy carried no camera.
What the department says, and what the video shows
Here is the police account, and it is being labeled that way on purpose.
Norman says an on-duty sergeant saw a truck make a U-turn and head south in the northbound lanes. Wrong way, on a freeway. Police say Harry displayed a gun. The sergeant fired. A gun was recovered at the scene, and the department has said it does not know whether that gun was ever fired.
Now the video. The truck is already stopped at the side of the highway as the sergeant pulls over. Harry gets out and walks around the back of it. The sergeant can be heard shouting “drop the gun.” Then what sounds like ten rounds, the sergeant backing up as he fires. Then a voice on the radio: “shots fired, shots fired.”
And here is the part that matters most. At the moment of the shooting, the sergeant’s own body sits between the camera and Harry. The lens cannot see what Harry did or did not do. The two seconds that determine whether this shooting was justified happened behind a man’s back.
The sergeant is 37 and has more than fifteen years with the department. He is on administrative duty, which is the standard step after a shooting and is not a finding of anything.
The argument for the policy, and why it fails here
The department’s position is not stupid, and it deserves to be stated properly before it is taken apart.
Sergeants supervise. Most of a shift is a car, a radio, and managing other people’s calls. A camera on a supervisor’s chest records a great deal of hallway and a great deal of paperwork. There is a real cost argument and a real storage argument underneath that, and they are not frivolous.
Here is where it breaks. Supervisors in this department do not only supervise. This one was alone on a freeway making contact with a driver. He did the job of a patrol officer, and then he did the most consequential thing a police officer can ever do. The rank did not keep him off the street. It only kept the camera off his chest.
You cannot write a policy that assumes a sergeant will never be first on scene. On November 2, a sergeant was the only one there.
A video that cannot show the decisive moment is not transparency. It is a partial release, and a partial release is how a department tells the public it followed the rule without answering the question.
One correction before it spreads
There is a story circulating that appears to be about this case and is not.
A widely shared piece reports that the family of a Milwaukee man shot by an officer called the shooting justified after viewing footage. That story concerns Elijah Wilks, 26, who was shot in October 2025 by an off-duty Milwaukee officer. Different man, different year, different case. The attorney quoted in it represents the Wilks family.
The family of Joseph Harry has said nothing publicly. No statement, no attorney, as of the evening of November 18. Urban News Journal checked WISN, FOX6 and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel before airing.
Both men were somebody’s person. Neither is served by the two cases being folded together.
The thread back to August
The Milwaukee Area Investigative Team has this case, which is standard. Milwaukee does not investigate its own shootings. The lead agency is the West Allis Police Department.
Readers of this outlet should recognize that name.
West Allis police wrote to Urban News Journal on October 7 to say the department holds no records, none, about what happened at the Wisconsin State Fair in August. No after-action report. No staffing records. No access-control records. They assisted, they said. They made no arrests. They have nothing.
Those two facts are not being presented as connected. What is being said is narrower and harder to dismiss: the department that produced nothing in response to a records request in October is now the lead investigator on a Milwaukee police killing. This outlet will be requesting records from West Allis again.
At City Hall, a pen that stayed in the drawer
The same pattern, in a gentler register, played out downtown.
Mayor Cavalier Johnson signed the 2027 city budget on November 17 and issued no vetoes. Not one. Urban Milwaukee’s Jeramey Jannene noted that the last Milwaukee city budget to pass with no vetoes at all was the 2015 budget.
The context is five years of losing. In 2022 Johnson issued vetoes and the Common Council overrode them. Same in 2023. Same in 2024. Last year he issued seven and the Council overrode every one of them unanimously. Fifteen members, zero defectors, seven for seven.
His statement reads, in part: “Here’s some good fiscal news for the city. In signing the 2027 Milwaukee city budget today, the council and I are largely in agreement on top priorities such as the record investment in our roads, maintaining public safety and supporting housing affordability.”
Then the line worth circling: “Some amendments to my proposed budget raise concerns, but we will work through those differences in the coming months.”
That is a man signing something he does not entirely like, and saying so politely, in paragraph two.
Alderwoman Marina Dimitrijevic, who chairs Finance and Personnel, was warmer: “I certainly thank Mayor Johnson for working closely with and honoring and respecting the work that we did.”
The line the administration did not want
The $1.35 million the Council borrowed to study a public takeover of We Energies survives. Alderman Alex Brower’s amendment passed 15-0 on November 6.
Look at how it is built. The amendment creates a task force the Council controls, which makes that money effectively the Council’s to spend rather than the administration’s. Reporting indicates people inside the administration were not supportive of borrowing for the study and were unhappy with the price. They were unhappy, they did not veto it, and now they do not hold the purse on it either. The city must hire outside expertise by February 1.
Precision matters here, because people are already running past the facts. $1.35 million buys a study. It does not buy a utility. It does not condemn anything. It does not lower a bill in January. It pays somebody to answer a question this city has never formally asked.
That question got less academic this month. The Public Service Commission approved We Energies increases of 3.9% for 2027 and 3.5% for 2028. That is six in a row.
What the budget costs you
The mayor’s own proposal carried about $45.20 on the average annual property tax bill. The Council’s amendments added roughly two dollars on top of that.
Meanwhile property owner fees, snow removal and street lighting, which nobody amended this year, rise $16.54 to $622.62 annually.
Two dollars from the people who took a vote. Seventeen from the people who did not have to. Watch where the money actually moves.
The rest: the Council replaced the mayor’s flat 2% raise with a Burgelis-Brower plan weighted toward the lowest-paid workers, about $6.2 million a year against the mayor’s $4.7 million. Squad car replacements were cut to replace a fire engine. Sunday library hours are back. An omnibus amendment trimmed the street parking fee increase and still put more into road repair.
The zoning rewrite nobody is reading, with a deadline
The Department of City Development released a package of proposed zoning changes on November 16. Not legislation. Proposals. But they amount to the largest rewrite of what you are allowed to build in this city in a long time.
Minimum home sizes disappear. In one single-family district a one-story house currently must be at least 1,200 square feet; that floor goes away. Minimum lot widths drop, 60 feet to 48 in one district, 75 to 55 in another. Downtown, floor area ratio formulas get replaced by coverage, setback and height rules, and the downtown core would carry no height limit at all. Cottage courts, three to twelve homes clustered together, become possible with special-use approval. Townhouses are allowed more widely.
What it does not do, and accuracy matters because people will say otherwise: it does not broadly legalize duplexes, triplexes and fourplexes inside single-family neighborhoods. Single-family stays one unit per building.
When this was attempted before, the objections were neighborhood character, displacement, and alderpersons losing a say over individual projects. Those are real arguments and they will return.
Public comment is open through December 11. Office hours run Friday, November 20, 1:00 to 5:30 p.m. at the Zeidler Municipal Building, 841 N. Broadway.
That is the window where ordinary residents get heard. After it closes, this moves to committee rooms and a Council vote.
Fourteen sentences, and a door nobody is opening
On November 18, Governor Tony Evers commuted the sentences of fourteen people in Wisconsin prisons, the first commutations by a Wisconsin governor since the Tommy Thompson administration.
The distinction matters, because the confusion around it does real damage. A pardon is official forgiveness, available in this state only to people who finished an entire sentence, including extended supervision, at least five years ago. A pardon is for somebody already out, and Evers has issued more than 2,400 of them. A commutation shortens a sentence somebody is still serving.
Most of these fourteen are still in prison. What changed for them is length, or the date they become eligible for parole. One person, a woman serving thirty years for burglary, was released outright with two years of supervision.
Two names, reported by Natalie Yahr and Brittany Carloni at Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service. Michael Maldonado was convicted of first-degree intentional homicide at fifteen, sentenced to life in 1995 with parole eligibility in 2044. His sentence was modified last year after, in the governor’s office’s language, new evidence showed he was not the gunman. He will now serve a maximum of four more years before transitioning to parole. Sammy Cole, convicted of armed robbery with threat of force in 2001, had thirty-five years cut to twenty-eight, citing his adjustment and rehabilitation inside.
Five of the fourteen were convicted when they were under eighteen.
The objection deserves real weight. Nathan Haberman, the Republican district attorney in Calumet County, wrote in July opposing Cole’s commutation: “There have been four circuit court judges who have reviewed the sentencing in this case,” adding that further second-guessing is not necessary nor appropriate.
Four judges looked at it. What makes a governor’s desk a better venue than four courtrooms? The honest answer is not that the district attorney is wrong. It is that courts apply the sentence that fit the day it was handed down, and clemency exists for what happened in the twenty-five years after. Those are different jobs. Reasonable people land differently on it.
The number nobody is covering
Shannon Ross runs a Milwaukee nonprofit called The Community and has been in this fight a long time. He is glad for these families: “It’s a great thing for them and their families that there’s daylight now in a place that had no daylight.”
Then he said the thing that should stop you. On parole: “This year has been a really, really slow, if not nonexistent, parole process.”
Department of Corrections data backs him. The parole board approved 77 people in 2025. This year, seven.
So consider what a commutation actually buys most of these fourteen. It does not open a door. It moves up the date they are allowed to knock on one. And the people on the other side are opening it about one-tenth as often as they did last year. Ross’s word for that risk was hollow.
Mercy that arrives at a counter nobody is staffing is not mercy yet.
The Commutation Advisory Board meets again on November 20 and December 11 to hear twenty-five more applicants, with decisions pending on twenty-three already heard. A spokesperson says the governor intends to at least approve or deny everyone who has had a hearing before he leaves office January 4.
January 4 is six and a half weeks out. After that this belongs to David Crowley, which is why this is not only a Madison story. In April, Crowley told Wisconsin Watch he would work to institutionalize the process, and that he would not allow commutations of murderers.
Hold both halves of that. Institutionalize it, meaning make it permanent rather than something that vanishes for twenty-five years. And a category he will not touch. Michael Maldonado, sentenced to life at fifteen, the man the governor’s own office says new evidence cleared as the gunman, was convicted of homicide.
How that line gets drawn in practice is a fair question for the man this county just sent to Madison. We intend to ask it.
Urban News Journal publishes new episodes Monday, Wednesday and Friday. The free newsletter goes out twice a week at urbannewsjournal.com. Tips and documents: press@marcus-hart.com.
Reporting sources: Urban Milwaukee, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service, CBS 58, FOX6, WISN, and Urban News Journal’s own correspondence with the West Allis Police Department.